What Happens When the Promise Meets Your Worst Night?
They were two completely different audiences, and both were fully with me.
I had done the work to understand who they were, customized the material, and it landed.
Not just polite applause, but standing ovations that were strong, long, and meaningful. The kind that makes you feel like everything is clicking into place.
I even had the thought, that might be as good as I’ve ever been!

And then, 36 hours later, I walked into a completely different experience.
It was a different city, a different crowd, and a 9:00 PM show—from Jason The Entertainer- the kind that has been my bread and butter for 25 years. If anything, the show has always been stronger than the keynote.
Not this night.
From the moment I started, people were talking. Not just a little here and there, but throughout the entire room.
Conversations layered over each other and kept getting louder as the night went on. It felt less like a performance and more like I was competing with the room for attention—and losing.
About thirty minutes in, I stopped and asked, “Is anyone actually listening… or should I just stop?”
There were some claps, enough to tell me there were people trying to engage, but the room never really came back. And for the first time in a long time, I wasn’t sure what the right move was.
That’s the danger of a great week. You start to believe you’ve figured something out, that you can count on the outcome. But one room can take that belief apart quickly and force a different question entirely:
Who are you when the room isn’t with you?

Because the promise was never that every room would respond. It was never that every performance would land the way you hoped. The real promise is that you show up fully, whether it comes back to you or not.
So I made a decision in that moment. I told the people who were listening, “I’m not going to punish you for what’s happening out there. If you’re here with me, I’m here with you.” And then I kept going.
Not because it was working, but because it was mine to give.
I adjusted as best I could. I tried different material, brought people on stage, shifted the energy, and worked to find something that would connect. Some moments did, most didn’t, and overall it remained one of the most difficult rooms I can remember.
And then, at the very end, they stood.
A standing ovation.
It didn’t really make sense in the moment. If I’m honest, it felt confusing more than validating. But what happened afterward mattered far more than what happened in the room.
Back in my hotel room, the messages started coming. Emails, texts, and direct messages from people in the audience. They were apologizing for the behavior of their peers—not casually, but genuinely.
They were embarrassed by what had happened, and they wanted me to know it wasn’t a reflection of the performance. They appreciated how I handled it, and many said they had tried to listen despite the chaos.
And the messages didn’t stop. They kept coming the next day, and the next, and have continued since, now a few weeks since this all happened.
Yesterday I got two more. Crazy!
That’s when something shifted for me.
The room I experienced in the moment wasn’t the full story. It felt like failure while I was standing in it, but it wasn’t the final outcome. The impact was still there—it just didn’t show up in the way I’m used to measuring it.
It reminded me of something simple, but easy to forget.
You don’t control how people receive what you give.
You don’t control the environment, the timing, or the distractions.
You only control whether you show up fully.
Sometimes what you give feels like it lands on nothing. But that doesn’t mean it didn’t land somewhere.
So the promise isn’t about perfect outcomes or consistent applause. It’s about consistency in who you are. It’s choosing to give your best even when it’s not returned. It’s refusing to let one moment rewrite your identity.
Because we all have those moments. At work, at home, in relationships—times where something doesn’t land the way we hoped.
The question isn’t whether they’ll happen. They will.
The question is what we do next.
Do we pull back, or do we stay steady and continue to give what we know we’re capable of giving?
Because character isn’t built in the moments where everything is going well. It’s revealed in the ones where it isn’t.
That night didn’t break anything for me. If anything, it clarified something I needed to remember.
One bad room doesn’t end a career. One bad night doesn’t define who you are.
The real story is what happens next.
So you keep showing up. You keep giving your best. And you keep the promise.

PS: If you’d like to see me talk about this, and hear more of the story, I go in depth into this experience on my podcast!

9 Responses
What happened to you validates a principle I taught my BYU students for two decades. Communication (where message sent is close to message received) is a MIRACLE. You give your best, of course. Then you have to factor in distractions, interference, overload, tech issues, personal problems, disabilities, even physical pain. If your message is understood, it’s a miracle. If it’s remembered its another miracle. If its acted on, it’s a miracle of the highest caliber.
Hand in hand with the Savior we try to communicate messages that matter. In ways that get the job done.
You’re one of the BEST.
Blessings, Elain
The way you reacted is a testament to your commitment to your promise. The reality is that we are not for everyone, but ultimately, in those tough moments, when you continue to show up fully, that’s what it’s all about. I’m glad you stuck to it – you are a shining example of professionalism, my friend. And thank you for sharing this story.
I continue to appreciate your authenticity and the lesson you derive from it and share with us.
You continue to be a blessing to many!
This is totally what I needed to hear today, as I’m also asking myself the question “Who am I when…” questions. Thank you for sharing your authenticity!
Kitty, you’re awesome. I’m grateful this lifts you up today!
Thanks, Jason, for your willingness to be vulnerable in your pursuit of keeping your Promise.
Means a lot, Cobey, thank you for commenting and these kind words.
Yes! Yes!! Great article.I love this so much. You stayed steady and delivered from your heart and from your complete totality and commitment. It’s humbling when these sorts of days happen, but I found that going to a deep place of trust, and pushing forward has always paid off as well. Thank you for sharing this powerful story.
You’re amazing Allison! I didn’t know you read my blog! LOL! You’re the best, thank you for this comment. #LEGEND